状态标签沿用 I021：MEASURED（直接测量，场散误差）、INFERRED（依赖模型）、CONDITIONAL（依赖明示假设）、CANDIDATE（非探测）、WITHDRAWN（不要引用）。本表为 2026-10-15 状态：C2（外区谱无 MOS2）已并入 L10、L11、L13；A1 能量审计的措辞更正已注明但尚未写入记录。
Status tags follow I021: MEASURED (direct, field-scatter errors), INFERRED (model-dependent), CONDITIONAL (rests on a stated assumption), CANDIDATE (not a detection), WITHDRAWN (do not cite). This table is the 2026-10-15 state: C2 (outer spectra without MOS2) is folded into L10, L11 and L13; the A1 audit wording corrections are noted but not yet applied to the records.
| # | 主张（当前措辞）Claim (current wording) | 状态Status | 2026-10-15 变更2026-10-15 change | 提交前检查Checks before submission |
|---|---|---|---|---|
L1 | ODF 重处理恢复曝光；逐相机耀发 GTI；风区 PN/MOS 1.07–1.12ODF reprocessing recovers the exposures; camera-level flare GTIs; PN/MOS 1.07–1.12 in the wind | MEASURED | — | C9 |
L2 | MOS1 CCD4 软超出制造假 ~1 keV 成分；MOS1 退出光谱The MOS1 CCD4 soft excess makes a false ~1 keV component; MOS1 is out of the spectra | MEASURED | — | — |
L2b | MOS1/MOS2 带卷帘依赖的望远镜坐标架大尺度梯度（N−S 0.7–1.2 PW/′）；PN 干净；原因未明MOS1 and MOS2 carry a roll-dependent, telescope-frame large-scale gradient (N−S 0.7–1.2 PW/′); PN is clean; cause open | MEASURED （原因未明）(cause open) | — | C2, C8 |
L3 | FXT v1.30 点源谱与 XMM 在 0.4–1 keV 一致到 0–10%FXT v1.30 matches XMM point-source spectra to 0–10% at 0.4–1 keV | MEASURED | — | — |
L4 | Chandra 目录 19 个条目是伪点源19 Chandra-catalogue entries are spurious | MEASURED | — | — |
L5 | ENE 轴上的背景星系团 WH24 J100242.9+554158（z 0.593）；已掩罩Background cluster WH24 J100242.9+554158 (z 0.593) on the ENE axis; masked | MEASURED | — | — |
L6 | X 形双极风，逐历元、逐仪器复现X-shaped bipolar wind, reproduced by epoch and by instrument | MEASURED | — | C1 |
L7 | 壁到 ~66 kpc：联合 PN+FXT B = 2.48 ± 0.43（5.8σ，39–55 kpc）、2.09 ± 0.67（3.1σ，55–66 kpc）；66 kpc 外无探测；FXT 60′ 壁发射率到 70–80 kpc（WSW，误差大）Walls to ~66 kpc: joint PN+FXT B = 2.48 ± 0.43 (5.8σ, 39–55 kpc) and 2.09 ± 0.67 (3.1σ, 55–66 kpc); no detection beyond 66 kpc; FXT 60′ wall emissivity to 70–80 kpc (WSW, large errors) | MEASURED | R1：55–66 kpc 是合并 bin，非端点（本手册已采纳）R1: the 55–66 kpc bin is pooled, not an endpoint (adopted in this handbook) | C1, C3 |
L8 | 45–90 kpc 无帽：联合折缘 K95 ≈ 1.4（50–70 kpc）/ 2.1（70–90 kpc）PW，60° 扇区；FXT 60′ 折叠 0.9–2.0 PW 到 110 kpc；0.7–2 keV 无热帽No cap at 45–90 kpc: joint fold rim K95 ≈ 1.4 (50–70 kpc) and 2.1 (70–90 kpc) PW, 60° sector; FXT 60′ fold 0.9–2.0 PW to 110 kpc; no hot cap at 0.7–2 keV | MEASURED | R1：模板依赖上限措辞（已采纳）R1: template-dependent-limit wording (adopted) | C4 |
L9 | WSW：46° 锥 → 36–41 kpc 近烟囱，上方空心；ENE：~45° 锥，~30–40 kpc 以上张开WSW: a 46° cone → a near-chimney at 36–41 kpc, hollow above; ENE: a ~45° cone, flaring above ~30–40 kpc | MEASURED （mock 标定）(mock-calibrated) | R1：轴对称 imposed（已采纳）R1: axisymmetry imposed (adopted) | C3 |
L10 | kT 0.25–0.31 keV（8–28 kpc）；壁 0.19–0.22 keV（41–61 kpc）；每高度壁与内部一个 kTkT 0.25–0.31 keV at 8–28 kpc; walls 0.19–0.22 keV at 41–61 kpc; one kT for wall and interior at each height | MEASURED | C2 完成（PN+FXT，无 MOS2）：WSW 壁 0.182、ENE 0.237 keV；所有相机对 ≤ 0.036 keV；L10 成立C2 done (PN+FXT, no MOS2): WSW walls 0.182, ENE 0.237 keV; all pairs move ≤ 0.036 keV; L10 stands | C5 (C2 done) |
L11 | 各高度 O-rich（1T O/Fe 5–10；17–28 kpc 排除太阳 ~3σ）；绝对值偏高；XMM/FXT 分裂 2.2–2.6×O-rich at all heights (1T O/Fe 5–10; solar rejected at 17–28 kpc by ~3σ); absolute value biased high; XMM/FXT split 2.2–2.6× | MEASURED （相对）(relative) CONDITIONAL （绝对）(absolute) | C2 PN+FXT：O/Fe 低 10–45%（壁 17–28 kpc 8.26→6.81）；pooled 区间未校准（e079_fit.py:220，R1 astra 发现、Claude 确认）；单区拟合不受影响C2 PN+FXT: O/Fe 10–45% lower (walls 17–28 kpc 8.26→6.81); pooled intervals uncalibrated (e079_fit.py:220, R1 astra, confirmed by Claude); single-region fits unaffected | C2, C5, C6 |
L12 | 47 kpc 晕：nH ≈ 5.5–5.8e-5，2σ ≤ 8.6e-5（FXT 60′；网格 ≤ 11.2e-5）；PN-only XMM ≤ 5.1–12.1e-5；P ≈ 4e-14Halo at 47 kpc: nH ≈ 5.5–5.8e-5, 2σ ≤ 8.6e-5 (FXT 60′; ≤ 11.2e-5 over rc/β/Rmin); PN-only XMM ≤ 5.1–12.1e-5; P ≈ 4e-14 | MEASURED （模型依赖）(model-dependent) | — | C7 |
L13 | 壁相对局部晕超压：WSW 2.95 ± 0.16（3-d 半径，FXT 60′），随高度持平；联合 PN 一致（2.7 / 2.3）Walls over-pressured against the local halo: WSW 2.95 ± 0.16 (3-d radius, FXT 60′), flat with height; joint PN agrees (2.7 / 2.3) | MEASURED （由 L12）(from L12) | C2（PN+FXT kT，固定密度）：WSW 2.95→2.87、ENE 2.6→2.83；误差仅壁归一化；斜率模型依赖（P2：16 个 HSE 晕 −0.45..+0.6）C2 (PN+FXT kT, fixed density): WSW 2.95→2.87, ENE 2.6→2.83; wall-only error; slope model-dependent (P2: 16 HSE halos, −0.45..+0.6) | C7 (C2 done) |
L14 | 现今风（L_kin < 2.7e40 erg/s）无法建造或供养该结构（×10–40）The present wind (L_kin < 2.7e40 erg/s) cannot build or feed the structure (×10–40) | INFERRED | R1：限定为"观测到的现今风相位不能供给"（本手册已采纳）R1: restricted to "the observed present-wind phase cannot supply" (adopted) | C2 (masses use L7/L13) |
L15 | 弱前向激波（Mach ~1.5–1.6）；每瓣 ≥ 3.4e57 erg；最佳匹配 ~100 Myr 情景，结束于 50–75 Myr 前；方法年龄 25–220 MyrA weak forward shock (Mach ~1.5–1.6); ≥ 3.4e57 erg per lobe; best match a ~100 Myr episode that ended 50–75 Myr ago; age 25–220 Myr by method | INFERRED （薄壳）(thin shell) | A1：100 Myr 情景注入功率 1.08–1.57e42 erg/s/lobe（3.40–4.94e57 erg/lobe；两瓣为 SN 功率的 2.7–3.9×）；7–9e41 是泡龄平均功率；能量下限条件于 Mach 1.60+引力分支；∝ P_halo(47 kpc)/4.1e-14。R1：Mach 推定非测量（对唯一激波史致命）。记录措辞待改A1: the 100 Myr episode needs injection power 1.08–1.57e42 erg/s per lobe (3.40–4.94e57 erg per lobe; 2.7–3.9× the SN power for two lobes); 7–9e41 is the age-averaged power; the energy floor holds only for the Mach 1.60 + gravity branch; scales as P_halo(47 kpc)/4.1e-14. R1: Mach is inferred, not measured (fatal to a unique shock history). Record wording to be fixed | C11 |
L16 | 光滑壁把 47 kpc 总晕压限制在 ≤ ~3 P_XSmooth walls limit the total halo pressure at 47 kpc to ≤ ~3 P_X | CONDITIONAL （条件于 f_w）(on f_w) | R1：撤回仅凭光滑外观的总压上限（本手册按条件性引用）R1: withdraw the total-pressure bound from smoothness alone (quoted conditionally here) | C11 |
L17 | L_X(0.5–2 keV, 14–80 kpc) ≈ 2e39 erg/s ≈ SN 功率的 0.25%L_X(0.5–2 keV, 14–80 kpc) ≈ 2e39 erg/s ≈ 0.25% of the SN power | INFERRED | R1：口径/模型依赖的快照比值，非积分反馈效率（已采纳）R1: an aperture/model-dependent snapshot, not an integrated efficiency (adopted) | C2 |
L18 | 前向激波鞘：未探测也未排除（上限 1.36–10× 预测）Forward-shock sheath: neither detected nor excluded (bounds 1.36–10× the prediction) | MEASURED / INFERRED | — | — |
L19 | WSW 14–28 kpc 软超出不具全局显著性The WSW 14–28 kpc soft excess is not globally significant | MEASURED | — | — |
L20 | FXT 小轴超出到 ~110 kpc 与 92–107 kpc 三个 blobFXT minor-axis excess to ~110 kpc and three blobs at 92–107 kpc | CANDIDATE | — | C4 |
L21 | PN-only XMM 的 55–66 kpc 轴发射（C +2.8 ± 1.0），FXT 无（+0.6 ± 0.8）Axis emission at 55–66 kpc in PN-only XMM (C +2.8 ± 1.0), not in FXT (+0.6 ± 0.8) | CANDIDATE | — | C12 |
来源Source: cognition-os/insights/I021_s09_paper_plan_v2.md; session 2026-10-15.md; 2026-10-15 job reports
来源Source: I021_s09_paper_plan_v2.md (withdrawn list); E083 handover